BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS
Does Not Accept Medicare AssignmentDoes Not Accept AssignmentYour share can be up to 15% above the Medicare-approved amount – ask for an itemized estimate before you order.
Opening hoursShow opening hours
About BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS
Brookhaven Opticians in Port Jefferson Stati, New York does one thing for Medicare patients: eyewear. Enrolled in Medicare since 2005, Brookhaven Opticians does not accept Medicare assignment on all items. Google reviewers rate it 4.7 stars from 36 reviews. It keeps weekday hours of 10 AM–6 PM. Patients in Port Jefferson Stati can contact the supplier directly to confirm coverage and availability.
Location
Open in Google Maps ↗Supplies & Services 1
MEDICARE COVERAGE & PATIENT GUIDE
Medicare Guide for PORT JEFFERSON STATI Patients
-
Orthotics, Prosthetics & Eyewear:
Medicare Part B covers artificial limbs and eyes, braces, and certain eyewear in PORT JEFFERSON STATI when they replace a missing body part or support a weakened one. Items wanted mainly for comfort or appearance are not covered.
What Medicare typically looks for:
- Leg, arm, back and neck braces are covered when your doctor documents that the brace is needed to support a weak, deformed or injured body part, or to hold it in the correct position.
- Artificial limbs and eyes are covered when the body part is missing or no longer functions; medically necessary repairs and replacements are covered when your physical condition changes.
- After cataract surgery in which a lens is implanted, Medicare covers one pair of conventional eyeglasses or contact lenses for that eye.
- Breast prostheses and mastectomy bras are covered after mastectomy surgery.
BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS does not accept Medicare assignment on all items, so your share may be higher — up to the federal limiting charge (no more than 15% above the Medicare-approved amount). Please ask for an itemized estimate before ordering.
Before your doctor visit
Most Medicare equipment delays are paperwork delays, not medical ones. The appointment where your doctor orders your equipment goes much further when you prepare for it — here is how.
Bring to every appointment
- Your Medicare card and a photo ID. The supplier copies your Medicare Beneficiary Identifier (MBI) exactly as printed, so bring the red, white and blue card itself — not just the number from memory.
- A list of your current medicines, and of any treatments or simpler equipment you have already tried for this problem. Your doctor's notes should show why those options are not enough.
- Recent test results and records connected with the equipment — lab work, sleep studies, therapy or hospital notes. Bring copies if you have them; records from another doctor's office often take days to transfer.
- The name of the supplier you plan to use — BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS in PORT JEFFERSON STATI — and ask the office to send the order and the visit notes directly to the supplier. Paperwork that sits in a chart is the most common cause of delays.
- Before you leave, ask whether the written order is complete. Medicare requires every equipment order to show your name or MBI, the order date, a description of the item, the quantity if there is one, and your practitioner's name and real signature — an order missing any of these gets sent back.
- For many higher-cost items — power wheelchairs and some hospital beds, for example — Medicare also requires an in-person visit with your treating practitioner within the 6 months before the order. If your last visit was by phone, or longer ago than that, tell the office when you book.
Getting ready: Orthotics, Prosthetics & Eyewear
- For therapeutic shoes, the appointment that counts is with the doctor who manages your diabetes — that doctor must certify your diabetes care and document a qualifying foot condition, so bring your diabetes history and be ready for a foot exam.
- Mention any previous foot ulcer, amputation, deformity, poor circulation or heavy callus, and bring the shoes and inserts you wear now. These findings need to be in your record, not just mentioned in conversation.
- For braces, show your doctor where the joint gives way or is deformed — Medicare looks for documented instability or deformity, and the type of fitting (custom-fitted or off-the-shelf) must match what the record supports.
Before you call BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS
Five minutes of preparation makes this call go further — the supplier can check your eligibility, confirm your likely costs and start the paperwork on the first try.
Have these ready
- Your Medicare card. The supplier will ask for your Medicare Beneficiary Identifier (MBI), exactly as printed on the card, to check that you are eligible.
- Your doctor's name, and the date of the visit where the equipment was discussed or ordered. The supplier will request the order and visit notes from that office — usually they handle the chasing for you.
- Your Medicare Advantage or other insurance card, if you have one. Plans other than Original Medicare can have different rules, networks and costs.
Ask on the call
- Do you accept Medicare assignment for this item? If the supplier accepts assignment, your share is limited to the Part B deductible plus 20% of the Medicare-approved amount.
- Will Medicare rent this item or buy it — and if it is rented, for how many months? Who do I call for servicing while it is rented?
- What is my likely share of the cost? Ask whether you have met your Part B deductible for the year, and for expensive items ask for the estimate in writing.
- What paperwork do you still need from my doctor — and once you have it, how long until the equipment is delivered?
- Do you deliver and set up the equipment, and show me how to use it? Is there any charge for delivery or setup?
- If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan: are you in my plan's network, and does my plan need to approve the order first (prior authorization)? An out-of-network supplier can cost you much more.
After your equipment arrives
Delivery day is not the end of the process. A few checks when the equipment arrives — and knowing who is responsible for what afterwards — can save you money and frustration.
On delivery day
- Check everything against the order before you sign: the right item, the right size, and every part and accessory on the list. You may refuse equipment that is wrong, damaged or incomplete.
- Sign only for what you actually received, and keep your copy of the delivery ticket. If you are asked to sign an Advance Beneficiary Notice (ABN), read it first — it means the supplier thinks Medicare might not pay, and signing can make you responsible for the full cost.
- Ask to be shown how to use, clean and store the equipment, and get the instructions in writing before the driver leaves.
- Keep BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS's service number with the equipment — (631) 331-0600 — and call them first if anything breaks or stops working.
Repairs, servicing and refills
- While Medicare is paying rent on equipment, the supplier owns it and is responsible for keeping it in working order — call them first for repairs or servicing during the rental period.
- When a capped-rental item becomes yours after the final rental month, Medicare can still help pay for medically necessary repairs. Keep your delivery paperwork so the supplier can verify the equipment.
- For oxygen, the supplier's duty lasts beyond the rent: after the 36-month rental ends, they must keep providing your oxygen and servicing the equipment for up to 5 years in total.
- Reorder supplies — masks, tubing, filters, dressings, test strips — before you run out. Suppliers usually need a few days, and Medicare pays only for quantities that match your documented need.
If a bill or a denial looks wrong
- Read your Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) and compare it with what you actually received. Wrong items, wrong quantities, and charges for things you never received do happen — call the supplier first to fix honest mistakes.
- Still not right? Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) and ask for an explanation of the claim.
- You have the right to appeal a decision you disagree with. The first step is called a redetermination, and you generally have 120 days from the date on the notice to request it — the notice itself explains how.
- You do not have to handle this alone: your SHIP program gives free help with bills and appeals. You will find their phone number in the free Medicare help section of this page.
- Protect your Medicare number. Never give it to someone who calls offering 'free' equipment you did not ask about — report suspicious calls to 1-800-MEDICARE.
Coverage and payment depend on medical necessity, eligibility, deductibles, supplier requirements, and applicable Medicare rules. Confirm benefits and any authorization requirements with Medicare or the provider.
FEDERAL REGISTRY & COMPLIANCE
CMS Federal Verification & Compliance Profile
Official federal enrollment, administrative identifiers, and executive registry.
National Provider ID (NPI)
Registered Specialties & Licenses
Durable Medical Equipment & Medical Supplies
Executive Leadership (E-E-A-T)
PAUL MASTROROCCO — President/Optician
Also Registered As
BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS
CMS Provider ID (DMEPOS)
Medicare Enrollment & Status
Active Standing
Pricing & Bidding Compliance
NPI Registration
Registered since 2007
Federal Exclusion Check
Not excluded from federal programs
Registry details are displayed from the supplied provider data. Verify current enrollment and contract status with the relevant federal source before relying on them for billing or coverage decisions.
CMS MEDICARE CLAIMS DATA
Medicare Activity in 2024
Medicare’s own claims records show how much this supplier actually did for Medicare patients in 2024 — the most recent year CMS has published.
What they provided most
The Medicare patients they serve
Their Medicare patients in 2024 were 75 years old on average.
Source: CMS Medicare DMEPOS utilization data (release RY26), calendar year 2024 — Original Medicare (fee-for-service) claims only; Medicare Advantage is not included. Totals are for this supplier’s Medicare provider number (NPI); a supplier with several locations under one NPI reports them together. CMS withholds very small product categories to protect patient privacy. The patient-mix figures are the age and condition shares CMS publishes for this supplier’s own Medicare patients.
LOCAL COMMUNITY HEALTH DATA
Local Community Health & Demographic Profile
Public health benchmarks and chronic disease prevalence within ZIP Code 11776.
For PORT JEFFERSON OPTICIANS INC, the most relevant community indicators are those connected to vision needs, routine healthcare engagement, and chronic conditions that may affect eye health and cataract risk. In ZIP code 11776, these benchmarks can help inform local outreach and service planning for prosthetic cataract lenses. Disclaimer: These public health benchmarks reflect regional community context and do not measure individual treatment demand or direct medication or device orders. About 24,205 people live in this ZIP code area, including some 19,188 adults. Two further local measures: vision disability among adults at 4.2%, and diabetes among adults at 9.7%. Among the measures tracked locally, high blood pressure among adults stands at 31.3%. Figures like these shape everyday demand for orthotics, prosthetics, and eyewear in the area.
Total Population
24,205
Residents in this ZIP/ZCTA
Population Age 18+
19,188
Residents aged 18 and older
Key Health Metrics
Selected indicatorsHigh Blood Pressure
High blood pressure is reported by 31.3% of adults in the area. Hypertension is an important chronic-health context for comprehensive eye care and may support outreach emphasizing routine medical follow-up and coordination with vision professionals. This community measure does not identify specific patients or indicate direct orders for prosthetic cataract lenses.
Vision Difficulty
Vision difficulty is reported by 4.2% of adults in the 11776 area. This is the most directly aligned indicator for an optical provider offering prosthetic cataract lenses and may support awareness campaigns focused on vision evaluation, cataract-related care coordination, and post-procedure optical support. The measure describes community-level vision status and does not predict an individual need for a prosthetic lens.
Routine Checkup
Routine checkups are reported by 81.1% of adults in the 11776 community, indicating a relatively high level of engagement with preventive healthcare. This may provide a useful channel for educational materials about cataract symptoms, vision referrals, and available optical support. The indicator reflects regional healthcare behavior and does not measure individual treatment demand or direct medication or device orders.
Diabetes
Diabetes affects 9.7% of adults locally. Because diabetes can be associated with eye complications and increased need for regular eye monitoring, this indicator may help guide educational partnerships and referral messaging with primary care and eye-care providers. It is a regional prevalence benchmark, not an estimate of cataract procedures or product demand.
How ZIP 11776 Compares With New York
CDC PLACES 2025 · vs state averageState average is the population-weighted average across all ZIP code areas in New York in the same CDC release. Figures are model-based CDC estimates for the adult population each measure covers, not counts of diagnosed patients.
Where ZIP 11776 stands in New York
Depression here is lower than 81% of ZIP codes in New York.
Stroke here is lower than 78% of ZIP codes in New York.
Source: CDC PLACES ZCTA Public Health Dataset (2025 Release).
MEDICARE FEE SCHEDULE RANGES
What Medicare Allows in New York
The range of amounts Medicare allows for the most common covered items in each category this supplier is authorized to bill for. A reference for comparing costs — not a price quote from this supplier.
Source: CMS DMEPOS Fee Schedule, October 2026. Each range spans the lowest and highest amounts Medicare published in New York (non-rural and rural rates) for the common covered items in that category. Amounts are per single item or unit, or the monthly rental for equipment Medicare rents. They are Medicare’s allowances, not this supplier’s prices and not what you would pay: your share depends on the Part B deductible, the 20% coinsurance, whether the supplier accepts assignment, and any supplemental coverage. Prescription drug categories and tube-feeding (enteral/parenteral) nutrition are not shown because Medicare pays for them under different schedules. The payment type shown for a category is Medicare’s payment category for the main equipment in that category, taken from the same fee schedule; individual supplies within a category can be paid differently, and the supplier can confirm how a specific item is handled. Item amounts shown under a category are this state’s non-rural rates for those specific items. Always confirm the exact price with the supplier before ordering.
FREE STATE & FEDERAL HELP
Free Medicare Help in New York
Free counseling and state programs that can lower what you pay for Medicare and prescription drugs.
Free Medicare Counseling (SHIP)
Health Insurance Information, Counseling and Assistance (HIICAP)
Trained counselors in New York provide free, unbiased help with Medicare: comparing plans, understanding bills and notices, and finding programs that lower your costs. SHIP counselors do not sell insurance and never charge for help.
1-800-701-0501State Help With Drug Costs (SPAP)
Elderly Pharmaceutical Insurance Coverage (EPIC)
For New York residents age 65 and older who are enrolled in a Medicare Part D plan, with income up to $75,000 if single or $100,000 if married. EPIC helps with Part D premiums and drug costs.
TTY: 1-800-290-9138
1-800-332-3742SHIP is a federally funded counseling program (Administration for Community Living); contacts follow the national SHIP directory at shiphelp.org. State program details and income limits can change, so please confirm eligibility with the program before applying.
COMMON QUESTIONS
Frequently Asked Questions
Straight answers drawn from this supplier’s federal record.
Is BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS a Medicare-enrolled supplier?
Yes. BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS is listed in the federal CMS directory of Medicare DMEPOS suppliers, with Medicare participation beginning in 2005, and is registered under NPI 1154443158. Enrollment means the supplier is authorized to bill Medicare for covered equipment and supplies, subject to Medicare coverage rules.
What does BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS bill Medicare for?
BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS is authorized to bill Medicare for 1 category, including Prosthetic Lenses: Prosthetics Cataract Lenses. Authorization to bill for a category is not a guarantee of stock on a given day, so call ahead to confirm availability.
Does BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS accept Medicare assignment?
Not on all items. Because BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS does not accept Medicare assignment across the board, your share can be higher — up to the federal limiting charge, which is no more than 15% above the Medicare-approved amount. Ask for an itemized estimate before you order.
How do I contact BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS?
You can reach BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS by phone at (631) 331-0600. The practice is located at 650 ROUTE 112 UNIT G, Port Jefferson Stati, NY 11776. Today (Wednesday), its listed hours are 10 AM–6 PM. Call ahead to confirm current hours and what you should bring.
What does Medicare allow for Prosthetic Lenses: Prosthetics Cataract Lenses in New York?
In New York, Medicare-approved amounts for Prosthetic Lenses: Prosthetics Cataract Lenses run $146 – $146 (October 2026 fee schedule). For example, Anter chamber intraocul lens (V2630) is $146. Medicare pays for these prosthetic lenses as a purchase. The approved amount is the ceiling Medicare allows, not a shelf price; when a supplier accepts assignment, your share is generally the Part B deductible plus 20% of that amount.
What does Medicare require for Orthotics, Prosthetics & Eyewear coverage?
Medicare Part B covers artificial limbs and eyes, braces, and certain eyewear in Port Jefferson Stati when they replace a missing body part or support a weakened one. Items wanted mainly for comfort or appearance are not covered. In particular: Leg, arm, back and neck braces are covered when your doctor documents that the brace is needed to support a weak, deformed or injured body part, or to hold it in the correct position.
Where can I get free help with Medicare in New York?
Health Insurance Information, Counseling and Assistance (HIICAP) offers free, unbiased Medicare counseling in New York as part of the national SHIP network. Call 1-800-701-0501 for help comparing coverage, understanding a bill or appealing a denial.
MORE MEDICARE SUPPLIERS
Medicare Suppliers Near Port Jefferson Stati
Port Jefferson Stati has 4 Medicare-enrolled DMEPOS suppliers, and 2 of them accept Medicare assignment. Suppliers in the city bill an average of 8.2 supply categories — BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS bills 1.
4 listed suppliers share ZIP code 11776.
Reviews for BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS (36)
What patients say on Google — the newest reviews patients and carers have left for BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS, shown as written. MedicineContact does not edit patient reviews.
I began using Brookhaven Opticians years ago and have always been impressed with the quality of care and expertise they provide.
Paul is the consummate professional and his depth of knowledge, impressive. Care and concern for those he serves is first and foremost.
For many years Brookhaven Opticians have provided me with the ultimate professional services. And more than that they are kind, friendly, and patient while I choose the perfect glasses for me. Thank you Paul for your help always. I would not go anywhere else!
Response from the owner
We loved helping you pick out an amazing pair of reading glasses……you could step into New York City with the pair we picked out and fit right in. Thank you for all your loyalty and trust for so many years. Thank you also for your kind words and sharing your experience.
Highly recommended. They helped me navigate the Medicaid/Medicare benefits for my father. Excellent customer service & extremely knowledgeable. You won’t be disappointed.
Response from the owner
Thank you for your kind words. We are thrilled to hear about your great experience. We love helping all our patients try to maximize their benefits though their vision plan. Thank you for choosing our office for your father’s eyewear needs.
After my cataract eye surgery I still needed to wear prescription glasses, and I had planned on getting new lenses for my four frames. I called Medicare to see if the lenses were covered by insurance, and was told that I could get one free "standard" frame along with the lenses, but the lenses/frame came together. I was still very happy at the news and called four opticians, thinking that they would all be connected to Medicare. Three of the four said they didn't know anything at all about free glasses from Medicare, but they offered a 10% discount from AARP. How nice of them.
It was only BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS, located in Port Jefferson Station, that had a knowledgeable, many years long, relationship with Medicare. Not only did I get a free pair of lenses, including a wider bifocal for easier reading, normally an extra $125.00, I was able to use my own beautiful frames. My "free pair" was worth over $600.00 + dollars.
Paul, the owner and President of BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS, worked on my other pairs of glasses, and everything came out perfectly the first time.
I can't say enough about the ease of this whole process, and the expertise that Paul displayed in working on all of my glasses. I also can't believe that I saved over $600.00 because Paul knew how to work with Medicare. I came away knowing that in the future, the only place I would go to for "anything" glasses, would be BROOKHAVEN OPTICIANS.
Response from the owner
Thank you for all your kind words and taking the time to write about your positive experience in our office. We have participated in the Medicare Post-Cataract eyeglass program for over 60 years and know the process well in order to maximize the Medicare eyeglass benefit for every patient after cataract surgery. We are honored to have you as our patient. Thank you again for your trust in our office and we will look forward to your continued loyalty.
I used to struggle to find eyeglasses for my young daughter. After being referred to Brookhaven Opticians, we never went anywhere else. We have been doing business with them for the last 14yrs. They are warm and caring, and customer focused. They have a large selection of frames, even for the little one. I highly recommend going to Brookhaven Opticians for all your eye care needs.
Response from the owner
Thank you for taking the time to share your positive experience in our office. We love your family and can’t thank you enough for all your continued support and loyalty for so many years. It’s patient’s like your daughter that make us love what we do. Thank you again for your kinds words.
We had a New prescription done for my son’s eye glasses there and they were very accommodating and very helpful. Highly recommend them.
Our whole family has been to Brookhaven Opticians either for eye exams, glasses or sunglasses. The staff is kind, patient and knowledgeable! They have many brands and selections to choose from. Paul is amazing at tracking down your favorite brands too! Definitely don’t miss this little gem and shop local.
Response from the owner
Thank you to your entire family for choosing our office and shopping local. We are one of the original second generation family owned businesses still in Smithtown……..it is because of families like yours that you continue to make us successful. Thank you also for your continued loyalty and support…..we love your entire family.
Excellent store and service!!
Response from the owner
Thanks so much for taking the time to write a review about your positive experience. Thank you also for your continued loyalty and support in our office. We look forward to your next visit.
I have been going to the Smithtown office.
I saw Scott and Paul there.
They provided an outstanding level of service.
My needs were a bit complicated and they were extremely patient and accommodating.
It didn't end there.
If I had any problems worth my glasses they were quite helpful resolving the issue.
Response from the owner
We loved the opportunity to take care of your eyewear needs. Thanks so much for your continued support and loyalty in our office. Thank your also for taking the time to share your positive experience in our office.
I purchased a pair a prescription sunglasses at a big box store, but they just didn’t cut it. I brought the same prescription to Brookhaven opticians. There was a world of difference. It just proves that you get what you pay for. Something else that was brought to my attention was that my insurance would cover part of my purchase. That was never mentioned to me at the big box store. I ended up paying the same price for a much higher quality of glasses at Brookhaven opticians. I would definitely recommend them.
Response from the owner
We pride ourselves in making you feel like “you are coming into the kitchen of our house” (Old Italian Expression) when we take care of our patients. We are happy to hear we “stand out” for our customer service and professionalism from the large retailers. Thank you also for your support of small business and giving us the opportunity to “Stand Out” from large retailers. We are honored to have you as our patient.
Showing the 10 newest of 36 reviews.
Read more reviews on Google MapsPatient reviews collected from Google in November 2026, shown as written — MedicineContact does not edit them. Ratings and counts can change on Google at any time.

