BENLY PHARMACY INC
Does Not Accept Medicare AssignmentDoes Not Accept AssignmentYour share can be up to 15% above the Medicare-approved amount – ask for an itemized estimate before you order.
Opening hoursShow opening hours
About BENLY PHARMACY INC
Benly Pharmacy is a specialty pharmacy in Islip, New York, built around prescription therapies rather than equipment shelves. Benly Pharmacy joined Medicare's supplier rolls in 2001; it does not accept assignment on every item. Google reviewers rate it 4.2 stars from 26 reviews. Federal records list its authorized official as Benny Mangalath, President.
Location
Open in Google Maps ↗Supplies & Services 6
MEDICARE COVERAGE & PATIENT GUIDE
Medicare Guide for ISLIP Patients
-
Medicare Part B Drugs:
Only a limited set of prescription drugs is covered under Part B instead of Part D for patients in ISLIP — mainly drugs given through medical equipment, plus a few categories named in the law. Each drug has its own strict conditions.
What Medicare typically looks for:
- Inhalation (nebulizer) drugs are covered only when administered at home through a Medicare-covered nebulizer.
- Immunosuppressive drugs are covered after an organ transplant that Medicare helped pay for, for as long as you need them to prevent rejection.
- Oral anticancer drugs are covered when the same active ingredient is also available in an injectable form; oral anti-nausea drugs are covered only as a full replacement for IV drugs given within 48 hours of chemotherapy.
- Drugs delivered through a home infusion pump are covered only when both the pump and the drug are medically necessary for your condition. Epoetin is covered for anemia tied to kidney disease or certain cancer treatments, under its own criteria.
BENLY PHARMACY INC does not accept Medicare assignment on all items, so your share may be higher — up to the federal limiting charge (no more than 15% above the Medicare-approved amount). Please ask for an itemized estimate before ordering.
Before your doctor visit
Most Medicare equipment delays are paperwork delays, not medical ones. The appointment where your doctor orders your equipment goes much further when you prepare for it — here is how.
Bring to every appointment
- Your Medicare card and a photo ID. The supplier copies your Medicare Beneficiary Identifier (MBI) exactly as printed, so bring the red, white and blue card itself — not just the number from memory.
- A list of your current medicines, and of any treatments or simpler equipment you have already tried for this problem. Your doctor's notes should show why those options are not enough.
- Recent test results and records connected with the equipment — lab work, sleep studies, therapy or hospital notes. Bring copies if you have them; records from another doctor's office often take days to transfer.
- The name of the supplier you plan to use — BENLY PHARMACY INC in ISLIP — and ask the office to send the order and the visit notes directly to the supplier. Paperwork that sits in a chart is the most common cause of delays.
- Before you leave, ask whether the written order is complete. Medicare requires every equipment order to show your name or MBI, the order date, a description of the item, the quantity if there is one, and your practitioner's name and real signature — an order missing any of these gets sent back.
- For many higher-cost items — power wheelchairs and some hospital beds, for example — Medicare also requires an in-person visit with your treating practitioner within the 6 months before the order. If your last visit was by phone, or longer ago than that, tell the office when you book.
Getting ready: Medicare Part B Drugs
- Bring a complete list of your medicines with doses. For Part B drugs, both the drug itself and how it is given — through a nebulizer, an infusion pump, or another covered method — affect coverage.
- If the drug follows a Medicare-covered transplant or cancer treatment, bring those dates and records. Some Part B drugs are covered only in those situations.
- Ask your doctor to note why the drug must be given this way instead of as a pill — for several Part B drug categories, that explanation is exactly what Medicare reviews.
Before you call BENLY PHARMACY INC
Five minutes of preparation makes this call go further — the supplier can check your eligibility, confirm your likely costs and start the paperwork on the first try.
Have these ready
- Your Medicare card. The supplier will ask for your Medicare Beneficiary Identifier (MBI), exactly as printed on the card, to check that you are eligible.
- Your doctor's name, and the date of the visit where the equipment was discussed or ordered. The supplier will request the order and visit notes from that office — usually they handle the chasing for you.
- Your Medicare Advantage or other insurance card, if you have one. Plans other than Original Medicare can have different rules, networks and costs.
Ask on the call
- Do you accept Medicare assignment for this item? If the supplier accepts assignment, your share is limited to the Part B deductible plus 20% of the Medicare-approved amount.
- Will Medicare rent this item or buy it — and if it is rented, for how many months? Who do I call for servicing while it is rented?
- What is my likely share of the cost? Ask whether you have met your Part B deductible for the year, and for expensive items ask for the estimate in writing.
- What paperwork do you still need from my doctor — and once you have it, how long until the equipment is delivered?
- Do you deliver and set up the equipment, and show me how to use it? Is there any charge for delivery or setup?
- If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan: are you in my plan's network, and does my plan need to approve the order first (prior authorization)? An out-of-network supplier can cost you much more.
After your equipment arrives
Delivery day is not the end of the process. A few checks when the equipment arrives — and knowing who is responsible for what afterwards — can save you money and frustration.
On delivery day
- Check everything against the order before you sign: the right item, the right size, and every part and accessory on the list. You may refuse equipment that is wrong, damaged or incomplete.
- Sign only for what you actually received, and keep your copy of the delivery ticket. If you are asked to sign an Advance Beneficiary Notice (ABN), read it first — it means the supplier thinks Medicare might not pay, and signing can make you responsible for the full cost.
- Ask to be shown how to use, clean and store the equipment, and get the instructions in writing before the driver leaves.
- Keep BENLY PHARMACY INC's service number with the equipment — (631) 581-7975 — and call them first if anything breaks or stops working.
Repairs, servicing and refills
- While Medicare is paying rent on equipment, the supplier owns it and is responsible for keeping it in working order — call them first for repairs or servicing during the rental period.
- When a capped-rental item becomes yours after the final rental month, Medicare can still help pay for medically necessary repairs. Keep your delivery paperwork so the supplier can verify the equipment.
- For oxygen, the supplier's duty lasts beyond the rent: after the 36-month rental ends, they must keep providing your oxygen and servicing the equipment for up to 5 years in total.
- Reorder supplies — masks, tubing, filters, dressings, test strips — before you run out. Suppliers usually need a few days, and Medicare pays only for quantities that match your documented need.
If a bill or a denial looks wrong
- Read your Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) and compare it with what you actually received. Wrong items, wrong quantities, and charges for things you never received do happen — call the supplier first to fix honest mistakes.
- Still not right? Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) and ask for an explanation of the claim.
- You have the right to appeal a decision you disagree with. The first step is called a redetermination, and you generally have 120 days from the date on the notice to request it — the notice itself explains how.
- You do not have to handle this alone: your SHIP program gives free help with bills and appeals. You will find their phone number in the free Medicare help section of this page.
- Protect your Medicare number. Never give it to someone who calls offering 'free' equipment you did not ask about — report suspicious calls to 1-800-MEDICARE.
Coverage and payment depend on medical necessity, eligibility, deductibles, supplier requirements, and applicable Medicare rules. Confirm benefits and any authorization requirements with Medicare or the provider.
FEDERAL REGISTRY & COMPLIANCE
CMS Federal Verification & Compliance Profile
Official federal enrollment, administrative identifiers, and executive registry.
National Provider ID (NPI)
Registered Specialties & Licenses
Pharmacy, Community/Retail Pharmacy
- Durable Medical Equipment & Medical Supplies
- Pharmacy (License 025146 – NY)
- Pharmacy, Specialty Pharmacy
Executive Leadership (E-E-A-T)
BENNY MANGALATH — PRESIDENT
Also Registered As
ISLIP PHARMACY AND SURGICAL
CMS Provider ID (DMEPOS)
Medicare Enrollment & Status
Active Standing
Pricing & Bidding Compliance
NPI Registration
Registered since 2006
Federal Exclusion Check
Not excluded from federal programs
Registry details are displayed from the supplied provider data. Verify current enrollment and contract status with the relevant federal source before relying on them for billing or coverage decisions.
CMS MEDICARE CLAIMS DATA
Medicare Activity in 2024
Medicare’s own claims records show how much this supplier actually did for Medicare patients in 2024 — the most recent year CMS has published.
What they provided most
They served 26% fewer Medicare patients than in 2022.
The Medicare patients they serve
Their Medicare patients in 2024 were 74 years old on average.
The conditions their patients most often live with: diabetes (78%), arthritis (78%), heart disease (74%).
Source: CMS Medicare DMEPOS utilization data (release RY26), calendar year 2024 — Original Medicare (fee-for-service) claims only; Medicare Advantage is not included. Totals are for this supplier’s Medicare provider number (NPI); a supplier with several locations under one NPI reports them together. CMS withholds very small product categories to protect patient privacy. The patient-mix figures are the age and condition shares CMS publishes for this supplier’s own Medicare patients.
LOCAL COMMUNITY HEALTH DATA
Local Community Health & Demographic Profile
Public health benchmarks and chronic disease prevalence within ZIP Code 11751.
BENLY PHARMACY INC serves the Islip, New York community with specialty therapies including oral anticancer and antiemetic medications, infusion drugs, immunosuppressive therapies, epoetin, and nebulizer medications. The selected indicators highlight local health conditions most closely aligned with these capabilities and can help guide community-focused service planning. Public health benchmarks reflect regional community context and do not measure individual treatment demand or direct medication orders. The area covered by ZIP 11751 counts roughly 14,790 residents, about 11,894 of them aged 18 and over. Local CDC figures estimate cancer (excluding skin cancer) among adults at 8.8%. Among the measures tracked locally, current asthma among adults stands at 10.7%.
Total Population
14,790
Residents in this ZIP/ZCTA
Population Age 18+
11,894
Residents aged 18 and older
Key Health Metrics
Selected indicatorsCOPD
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease affects an estimated 5.8% of adults in ZIP code 11751. The measure is relevant to nebulizer medications and respiratory-care support. UI opportunity: present information about inhalation-treatment education, medication schedules, and coordination with clinicians for patients managing chronic breathing conditions.
Cancer
Cancer affects an estimated 8.8% of adults in ZIP code 11751. This indicator is highly relevant to BENLY PHARMACY INC’s oral anticancer, infusion, and oral antiemetic services. UI opportunity: highlight coordinated specialty-pharmacy support, medication education, adherence assistance, and symptom-management resources for patients and caregivers.
Asthma
Current asthma affects approximately 10.7% of adults in the local area. This benchmark aligns with the pharmacy’s nebulizer-drug capabilities and supports emphasizing respiratory medication counseling, device-use education, refill coordination, and access support for asthma management.
Arthritis
Arthritis affects approximately 24.5% of adults in the community. This indicator is relevant to the pharmacy’s immunosuppressive and infusion-drug capabilities, which may support treatment plans for certain inflammatory conditions. UI opportunity: emphasize specialty medication counseling, infusion coordination, monitoring reminders, and ongoing adherence support.
How ZIP 11751 Compares With New York
CDC PLACES 2025 · vs state averageState average is the population-weighted average across all ZIP code areas in New York in the same CDC release. Figures are model-based CDC estimates for the adult population each measure covers, not counts of diagnosed patients.
Where ZIP 11751 stands in New York
Stroke here is lower than 82% of ZIP codes in New York.
Diabetes here is lower than 81% of ZIP codes in New York.
Source: CDC PLACES ZCTA Public Health Dataset (2025 Release).
FREE STATE & FEDERAL HELP
Free Medicare Help in New York
Free counseling and state programs that can lower what you pay for Medicare and prescription drugs.
Free Medicare Counseling (SHIP)
Health Insurance Information, Counseling and Assistance (HIICAP)
Trained counselors in New York provide free, unbiased help with Medicare: comparing plans, understanding bills and notices, and finding programs that lower your costs. SHIP counselors do not sell insurance and never charge for help.
1-800-701-0501State Help With Drug Costs (SPAP)
Elderly Pharmaceutical Insurance Coverage (EPIC)
For New York residents age 65 and older who are enrolled in a Medicare Part D plan, with income up to $75,000 if single or $100,000 if married. EPIC helps with Part D premiums and drug costs.
TTY: 1-800-290-9138
1-800-332-3742SHIP is a federally funded counseling program (Administration for Community Living); contacts follow the national SHIP directory at shiphelp.org. State program details and income limits can change, so please confirm eligibility with the program before applying.
COMMON QUESTIONS
Frequently Asked Questions
Straight answers drawn from this supplier’s federal record.
Is BENLY PHARMACY INC a Medicare-enrolled supplier?
Yes. BENLY PHARMACY INC is listed in the federal CMS directory of Medicare DMEPOS suppliers, with Medicare participation beginning in 2001, and is registered under NPI 1396843322. Enrollment means the supplier is authorized to bill Medicare for covered equipment and supplies, subject to Medicare coverage rules.
What does BENLY PHARMACY INC bill Medicare for?
BENLY PHARMACY INC is authorized to bill Medicare for 6 categories, including Epoetin, Immunosuppressive Drugs, Infusion Drugs, Nebulizer Drugs, and 2 more. Authorization to bill for a category is not a guarantee of stock on a given day, so call ahead to confirm availability.
Does BENLY PHARMACY INC accept Medicare assignment?
Not on all items. Because BENLY PHARMACY INC does not accept Medicare assignment across the board, your share can be higher — up to the federal limiting charge, which is no more than 15% above the Medicare-approved amount. Ask for an itemized estimate before you order.
How do I contact BENLY PHARMACY INC?
You can reach BENLY PHARMACY INC by phone at (631) 581-7975. The practice is located at 437 MAIN ST, Islip, NY 11751. Today (Tuesday), its listed hours are 9 AM–7 PM. Call ahead to confirm current hours and what you should bring.
What does Medicare require for Medicare Part B Drugs coverage?
Only a limited set of prescription drugs is covered under Part B instead of Part D for patients in Islip — mainly drugs given through medical equipment, plus a few categories named in the law. Each drug has its own strict conditions. In particular: Inhalation (nebulizer) drugs are covered only when administered at home through a Medicare-covered nebulizer.
Where can I get free help with Medicare in New York?
Health Insurance Information, Counseling and Assistance (HIICAP) offers free, unbiased Medicare counseling in New York as part of the national SHIP network. Call 1-800-701-0501 for help comparing coverage, understanding a bill or appealing a denial.
Reviews for BENLY PHARMACY INC (26)
What patients say on Google — the newest reviews patients and carers have left for BENLY PHARMACY INC, shown as written. MedicineContact does not edit patient reviews.
Do not give this store your business; they are professional gas lighters who did not explain the return policy to me. The person who I spoke with named Grace was laughing at me during the phone conversation saying that I was told about the return policy, and I explained that was not true. She called me a liar and laughed some more saying that I should have known better we are a medical supply store. Do not give this store your business.
Response from the owner
Thank you! We're glad you had a great experience at Islip Pharmacy and Surgical.
Tony from pharmacy is very disrespectful, unprofessional and rude. If you use this pharmacy talk to anyone else but him.
Response from the owner
Hello Bradley, Thank you for letting us know about your recent experience. We're sorry you had a bad experience. Please take a moment to contact us so we can discuss your concerns.
Islip Pharmacy is an efficient, well run pharmacy. They are on top of your prescriptions and text or call to remind you to refill your prescriptions. I have been going to this pharmacy for over 30 years. They go above and beyond to obtain specialized medications. I highly recommend using them to fulfill all your medication requirements.
Response from the owner
Thank you so much! We appreciate that you took the time to share your experience with us. It's our pleasure to continue to serve kind customers such as yourself. Thanks again and we hope to see you back soon!
Response from the owner
Thank you, Maria! We're glad you had a great experience at Islip Pharmacy.
I moved to bayshore and still go there allbthe people that work there are so friendly
Response from the owner
Thank you so much! We appreciate that you took the time to share your experience with us. It's our pleasure to continue to serve kind customers such as yourself. Thanks again and we hope to see you back soon!
I have been coming here for over 40 years. Nice community pharmacy. They have always treated me good. The only reason I am not giving it 5 stars is because the large old-fashioned black clock they have hanging over the pharmacy area has over 40 years of dust on it and just ruins the vibe. The Christmas wreaths they constantly keep displayed on each side of it need to go too. But overall, always a good experience
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for the kind words. We're truly grateful to have the support of customers like you. We'll make sure to pass on your kind words to the rest of our pharmacy staff. We'd love to continue to provide great services to awesome customers like you. Come back and see us soon!
Great service. Quick with filling prescriptions
Response from the owner
Thank you so much for the kind words. We're truly grateful to have the support of customers like you. We'll make sure to pass on your kind words to the rest of our pharmacy staff. We'd love to continue to provide great services to awesome customers like you. Come back and see us soon!
The pharmacists and staff at Islip Pharmacy are always professional and courteous . They counsel their clients as to all aspects of their medications and are always available for qustions and follow-up. They are proactive in contacting prescribing physicians as medications need refills. Definitely an asset to our community..
Response from the owner
Thanks for sharing! We love to hear such wonderful things from our customers. We work really hard to offer quality services in a friendly environment, so I'm so glad to see that reflected in your last visit! We really appreciate you being a loyal customer and helping to share the word about us. We look forward to working with you again in the future!
Showing the 10 newest of 26 reviews.
Read more reviews on Google MapsPatient reviews collected from Google in November 2026, shown as written — MedicineContact does not edit them. Ratings and counts can change on Google at any time.
